Kajian terbesar tentang orang yang mengambil madu Sidr setiap hari
Doctors in Saudi Arabia followed 1,000 people for a year. Half took 20ml of Sidr honey daily, half took a standard pharmacy syrup, and the two groups were compared.
1,000
orang, diikuti selama setahun
Kumpulan madu melaporkan hasil lebih awal berbanding kumpulan sirap, dan melaporkan lebih sedikit kesan sampingan.
people, out of 500 in each group
Sidr honeyPharmacy syrup
- The problem came back059
- Needed the dose changed0128
- Had to stop taking it037
days — shorter is sooner
- Sidr honey1.75 days (range 0.5–3)
- Pharmacy syrup3.25 days (range 2–5)
The study in brief
- people
- 1,000
- in each group
- 500
- of Sidr honey a day
- 20 ml
- of follow-up
- 1 year
Where this sits
- In the laboratory
- In animals
- In people
The strongest kind of evidence: the effect measured in people.
See all the numbers
| Sidr honey | Pharmacy syrup | |
|---|---|---|
| The problem came back | 0 | 59 (11.8%) |
| Needed the dose changed | 0 | 128 (25.6%) |
| Had to stop taking it | 0 | 37 (7.4%) |
Out of 500 people in each group. Each difference was statistically significant.
Worth knowing
The full summary
Hampir setiap kajian tentang madu Sidr dijalankan dalam piring makmal atau pada haiwan. Ini pengecualian yang jarang — orang sebenar, memakan madu sesudu demi sesudu, dalam tempoh yang cukup panjang untuk bermakna.
Everyone in the honey group stayed on the daily 20ml for the whole year, and none of the 500 reported the problem coming back. In the syrup group, 59 did.
Saiznya yang menjadikannya luar biasa. Seribu orang selama dua belas bulan lebih besar daripada hampir semua kajian lain yang diterbitkan tentang madu ini.
Three comparisons, one direction
The paper reports three tests between the groups: time to the first result (p = 0.0021), a result that held over the year (p = 0.0011) and side effects (p = 0.0023). All three favoured the honey group.
