Mantuvo el mismo ritmo que un antiséptico estándar en heridas contaminadas
Investigadores veterinarios en Jordania trataron heridas contaminadas en perros con miel de Sidr o con povidona yodada, el antiséptico estándar, y siguieron la cicatrización mediante fotografías y análisis de imagen durante 28 días.
Tan bien como
la povidona yodada, el antiséptico estándar con el que se comparó
La miel y el antiséptico evolucionaron de forma muy similar durante 28 días, sin diferencias medibles entre ambos.
% of the wound closed — higher is further along
- Sidr honey22.76% → 96.41%
- Povidone-iodine19.27% → 96.53%
- Day 7
- Day 14
- Day 21
- Day 28
The study in brief
- dogs, each its own control
- 8
- wounds: 16 per treatment
- 32
- photographed and measured weekly
- 28 days
- honey-treated wounds fully covered; day 27 for the antiseptic
- Day 26
Where this sits
- In the laboratory
- In animals
- In people
A step beyond the laboratory dish: the effect measured in a living body.
See all the numbers
| Sidr honey | Povidone-iodine | |
|---|---|---|
| Day 7 | 22.76% | 19.27% |
| Day 14 | 55.52% | 49.38% |
| Day 21 | 87.45% | 86.37% |
| Day 28 | 96.41% | 96.53% |
Average wound contraction. None of the differences was statistically significant.
Worth knowing
The full summary
Povidone-iodine is the antiseptic a clinic reaches for. Over 28 days, wounds treated with Sidr honey closed at the same pace as wounds treated with it.
Matching a standard antiseptic is a higher bar than beating an untreated wound.
La medición se hizo fotografiando las heridas cada semana y analizando las imágenes con un programa informático, en lugar de a simple vista, lo que elimina buena parte de la subjetividad.
A hard test on purpose
The wounds were deliberately contaminated, then left uncovered to heal on their own. None became infected under either treatment.
