Yemen Sidr Honey
دراسة مخبريةاختُبر في طبق مخبري2015

Eleven honeys against wound bacteria: the two strongest were both Sidr

A researcher at King Saud University tested eleven undiluted honeys against 24 strains of bacteria taken from wounds, then looked at what the two strongest honeys did to the bacterial cells.

2 of 11

honeys led on all three bacteria, and both were Sidr

Southern Sidr and Yemen Sidr honey cleared the widest zones against all three kinds of bacteria. Seven of the other nine honeys had no effect on at least two kinds.

Cleared zone against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus

mm — wider is stronger

  • Southern Sidr honey⁦15 mm⁩
  • Yemen Sidr honey⁦14 mm⁩
  • Hungarian honey⁦9 mm⁩
  • Multi-flower mountain honey⁦9 mm⁩
  • Kashmiri Sidr honey⁦8 mm⁩
  • The other six honeysno zone

The study in brief

honeys, tested undiluted
11
strains from wounds, eight of each kind
24
honeys that stopped all three kinds, three of them Sidr
4
honeys that cleared nothing
3

مستوى الدليل

  1. في المختبر
  2. على الحيوانات
  3. على البشر

Measured directly, under controlled laboratory conditions.

See all the numbers
Cleared zone around each honey
Staphylococcus aureusMethicillin-resistant S. aureusPseudomonas aeruginosa
Southern Sidr17 ± 1.3515 ± 0.7118 ± 3.44
Yemen Sidr15 ± 2.5814 ± 2.8315 ± 2.42
Multi-flower mountain13 ± 3.249 ± 1.111 ± 2.38
Kashmiri Sidr9 ± 0.588
Al-Madinah0011 ± 0.7
Black seed0010 ± 2.16
Yemen Thorn0010
Hungarian09 ± 1.20
Clover, cotton and date000

Average width in mm, with the spread the paper gives. 0 means no cleared zone.

جدير بالمعرفة

The full summary

A disc soaked in honey is placed on a plate of bacteria. If the honey stops them, a clear ring forms around the disc, and the wider the ring, the stronger the effect.

Yemen Sidr honey cleared ⁦15 mm⁩ against ordinary Staphylococcus aureus, ⁦14 mm⁩ against the methicillin-resistant kind and ⁦15 mm⁩ against Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Southern Sidr was slightly ahead at 17, 15 and ⁦18 mm⁩. The next best honey managed 13, 9 and 11.

Clover, cotton and date honey cleared nothing at all. Only four of the eleven stopped all three kinds of bacteria: the three Sidr honeys, from Yemen, the south and Kashmir, and one mountain honey.

What the honey did to the cells

After the Sidr honeys, the bacteria took up more of a dye that an intact cell wall keeps out. For Pseudomonas, uptake went from 43.4% untreated to 74% with Yemen Sidr and 92.4% with Southern Sidr. For the resistant Staphylococcus it went from 36.4% to 45.2% and 58.4%.

Honey and antibiotic discs together

Antibiotic discs dipped in honey were also tried. Combining vancomycin with the Hungarian honey widened the cleared zone by ⁦7 mm⁩.